The duhem quine thesis

Consider, first, whether possessing evidence is sufficient for justified belief. Some think that justified belief is essentially a deontological notion, involving the fulfillment of one's duties or responsibilities as a believer. Hence, while having a belief that fits one's evidence might be implicated in responsible belief, it seems that responsibility also requires making proper use of one's evidence. For example, suppose I am justified in believing p , and that I am justified in believing that if p then q . Yet, I do not believe q on the basis of this evidence, but believe it simply because I like the way it sounds (Korblith, 1980). If I believe q on these grounds, I am arguably not justified in my belief, even though it "fits" my other beliefs; believing a proposition because of the way it sounds seems like a patently irresponsible and therefore unjustified belief, no matter what unused evidence for it I may possess. In defense of evidentialism here, Conee and Feldman appeal to the auxiliary notion of a well-founded belief: a belief that not only fits the evidence a person possesses, but is properly based upon it. Thus, in the above example, my belief in q is not well-founded, since I do not properly use my evidence, even though the belief is justified by the evidence I possess. This maneuver may do little, however, to placate those who take justified belief to be inextricably related to responsibility.

Learn more

the duhem quine thesis

The duhem quine thesis

Action Action

the duhem quine thesis

The duhem quine thesis

Action Action

the duhem quine thesis

The duhem quine thesis

Action Action

the duhem quine thesis
The duhem quine thesis

Action Action

The duhem quine thesis

Action Action

the duhem quine thesis

The duhem quine thesis

Action Action

the duhem quine thesis

The duhem quine thesis

Action Action

the duhem quine thesis

The duhem quine thesis

Action Action

Bootstrap Thumbnail Second

The duhem quine thesis

Action Action

Bootstrap Thumbnail Third

The duhem quine thesis

Action Action